I have never really used the tag system, so perhaps this is a dumb question. Which pages do get these tags? The purpose of the page we are commenting on here was to solve the problem that Diagrams in Comments often have been pushed very much backwards, so that you have to scan through several pages of Comments to find them. And even where this is not the case it could become like that in the future. The number of Comments preceding them can only increase. When using the overview page it would open the relevant comment directly, in isolation, so that there can also be no interference with Diagrams that might have been posted close to it, and are displayed on the same page.
If the tags would only bring you to the main page of the article, it would not really solve this problem.
Of course Diagrams could be moved to the main page. But there often is a reason that I posted those in a Comment. Usually because they could not implement the rules perfectly, or I considered them sub-standard in other ways. The long-term goal is to equip nearly every article with an I.D. on its main page, and then all problems would have vanished completely. We would not even need a tag, because it would go without saying that people can expect an I.D. in the article. But this would require still significant work to be done on the Diagram script.
I have never really used the tag system, so perhaps this is a dumb question. Which pages do get these tags? The purpose of the page we are commenting on here was to solve the problem that Diagrams in Comments often have been pushed very much backwards, so that you have to scan through several pages of Comments to find them. And even where this is not the case it could become like that in the future. The number of Comments preceding them can only increase. When using the overview page it would open the relevant comment directly, in isolation, so that there can also be no interference with Diagrams that might have been posted close to it, and are displayed on the same page.
If the tags would only bring you to the main page of the article, it would not really solve this problem.
Of course Diagrams could be moved to the main page. But there often is a reason that I posted those in a Comment. Usually because they could not implement the rules perfectly, or I considered them sub-standard in other ways. The long-term goal is to equip nearly every article with an I.D. on its main page, and then all problems would have vanished completely. We would not even need a tag, because it would go without saying that people can expect an I.D. in the article. But this would require still significant work to be done on the Diagram script.