H. G. Muller wrote on Wed, May 22, 2019 07:45 AM UTC:
But I'm not sure what the "correct" notations would be anyway. I have assigned letters already but you probably won't like them. I abandoned Betza's terrible, horrible, absolutely no good names at least a decade ago, using alternatives when they already existed.
I completely agree. I am all in for renaming them, but I do think it is important we do it in the same way. 'Phoenix' is great, but what ID do you use, as the P is already taken? I would use 'X', as that is otherwise in little demand. 'Short Rook' (S) for the R4 would also be an obvious choice. I always liked the name 'Tower' for Rookish pieces (as there is also little pressure on T), but am not sure whether that would best fit the WD or the Charging Rook. 'Lighthouse' would also be a suitable name for an augmented Rook. 'Duck' for the HFD seems as good a name as any. Fairy-Max used 'Unicorn' for the Charging Knight, but this has already a Grant Acedrex meaning. How about 'Jockey' for a Horse/Man-like piece (other than the KN Centaur)? The Bede should probably have the name of some sort of (rather important) cleric. How about 'Ayatollah'? The FAD gives the impression of nervously jumping around, but the name Squirrel is already taken. It can be seen as an augmented Modern Elephant, but that seems a misnomer for a jumping piece in the first place. 'Kangaroo' would be fitting, but has occasionally been used for several other pieces.
I completely agree. I am all in for renaming them, but I do think it is important we do it in the same way. 'Phoenix' is great, but what ID do you use, as the P is already taken? I would use 'X', as that is otherwise in little demand. 'Short Rook' (S) for the R4 would also be an obvious choice. I always liked the name 'Tower' for Rookish pieces (as there is also little pressure on T), but am not sure whether that would best fit the WD or the Charging Rook. 'Lighthouse' would also be a suitable name for an augmented Rook. 'Duck' for the HFD seems as good a name as any. Fairy-Max used 'Unicorn' for the Charging Knight, but this has already a Grant Acedrex meaning. How about 'Jockey' for a Horse/Man-like piece (other than the KN Centaur)? The Bede should probably have the name of some sort of (rather important) cleric. How about 'Ayatollah'? The FAD gives the impression of nervously jumping around, but the name Squirrel is already taken. It can be seen as an augmented Modern Elephant, but that seems a misnomer for a jumping piece in the first place. 'Kangaroo' would be fitting, but has occasionally been used for several other pieces.