I can't imagine this game was ever played much, or if played much, ever
played well.
If the second player adopts a symmetrical defense, then the first player
is forced to sacrifice material, possibly a lot of material, in order to
break symmetry. The only way to break symmetry is to capture one ship
(rook) with another down a file, or to check the enemy king. But either
of these require opening a gap in the pawn structure, and the second
player can always come out ahead materially in the process of opening such
a gap.