Check out Atomic Chess, our featured variant for November, 2024.

Enter Your Reply

The Comment You're Replying To
H. G. Muller wrote on Tue, Feb 21, 2012 11:31 AM UTC:
> 22. Pieces belong to a player.

Good point. It did not occur to me to mention this, but for me it carries as least as much weight as any other of the characteristics I mentioned.

OTOH, I would not put any weight on things like 'pieces should move like Chess pieces' or 'Can be played with Chess board and pieces'. This seems to single out a specific variant (namely Mad Queen) as overwhelmingly more important than the others. While IMO it is just one of the many Chess variant, and not even the most popular one on the planet.

Furthermore, a point system should take into account that the characteristics are not just boolean all-or-nothing things. For my perception of Chess-likeness it definitely matters if the rules are mildly violated (e.p. capture and castling in Mad Queen), or badly violated (e.g. almost no piece captures by replacement, as in Ultima). So the question is more if the typical behavior satisfies the requirements, rather than that no exception at all is tolerated.

The concept of 'recognized variant', in the sense of very widely played, should probably play some rule too. For instance, if a game is on the edge w.r.t. the number and severity of how it violates the defining characteristics, it should never be pushed over the edge based on whether it also allows e.p. capture or not. This particular transgression of the replacement-capture requirement should be designated 'acceptable' because it is so common (which no doubt can be traced back to the popularity of the recognized variant that incorporates it.)

There also seems to be need to weight the opposite: likeness to very popular games recognized to be not Chess variants. If Checkers would be recognized as an independent game, (which I think the vast majority of people would agree on), I would be inclined to reject games that are more like Checkers than like Chess, even if in an objective measure they are closer to Chess than some other variants which do not happen to be close to any other recognized game either.

Edit Form

Comment on the page On Designing Good Chess Variants

Conduct Guidelines
This is a Chess variants website, not a general forum.
Please limit your comments to Chess variants or the operation of this site.
Keep this website a safe space for Chess variant hobbyists of all stripes.
Because we want people to feel comfortable here no matter what their political or religious beliefs might be, we ask you to avoid discussing politics, religion, or other controversial subjects here. No matter how passionately you feel about any of these subjects, just take it someplace else.
Avoid Inflammatory Comments
If you are feeling anger, keep it to yourself until you calm down. Avoid insulting, blaming, or attacking someone you are angry with. Focus criticisms on ideas rather than people, and understand that criticisms of your ideas are not personal attacks and do not justify an inflammatory response.
Quick Markdown Guide

By default, new comments may be entered as Markdown, simple markup syntax designed to be readable and not look like markup. Comments stored as Markdown will be converted to HTML by Parsedown before displaying them. This follows the Github Flavored Markdown Spec with support for Markdown Extra. For a good overview of Markdown in general, check out the Markdown Guide. Here is a quick comparison of some commonly used Markdown with the rendered result:

Top level header: <H1>

Block quote

Second paragraph in block quote

First Paragraph of response. Italics, bold, and bold italics.

Second Paragraph after blank line. Here is some HTML code mixed in with the Markdown, and here is the same <U>HTML code</U> enclosed by backticks.

Secondary Header: <H2>

  • Unordered list item
  • Second unordered list item
  • New unordered list
    • Nested list item

Third Level header <H3>

  1. An ordered list item.
  2. A second ordered list item with the same number.
  3. A third ordered list item.
Here is some preformatted text.
  This line begins with some indentation.
    This begins with even more indentation.
And this line has no indentation.

Alt text for a graphic image

A definition list
A list of terms, each with one or more definitions following it.
An HTML construct using the tags <DL>, <DT> and <DD>.
A term
Its definition after a colon.
A second definition.
A third definition.
Another term following a blank line
The definition of that term.