Derek Nalls wrote on Sat, Dec 10, 2005 09:58 PM UTC:
Please forgive my unclear writing.
I meant that our respective essays have very distinct purposes.
Mine is mainly documentation for a specific game, justifying its features in terms of likes and dislikes (based upon reason) with a maximum of value judgments.
Yours is an educational article of general purpose which should contain a minimum of value judgments (although quality itself unavoidably entails
value judgments). Hopefully, many people will benefit from reading it
over the years.
I meant that our respective essays have very distinct purposes.
Mine is mainly documentation for a specific game, justifying its features in terms of likes and dislikes (based upon reason) with a maximum of value judgments.
Yours is an educational article of general purpose which should contain a minimum of value judgments (although quality itself unavoidably entails value judgments). Hopefully, many people will benefit from reading it over the years.