Comments/Ratings for a Single Item
In my game with Jeremy Good -- Hostage Chess game http://play.chessvariants.org/pbm/play.php?game=Hostage+Chess&log=michaeljay-cvgameroom-2006-93-166 I am having some difficulty transferring freed pieces during exchanges from the grey prison area to free blue area. The system will allow the player on move to drop a piece, but the opponent's freed piece will not move to the blue area, even when attempted manually. As a result, pieces do not appear available to the opponent, even when the potentially-droppable piece is free.
I missed his previous comment, but there is nothing to fix. The problem is nothing more than that he doesn't understand how the notation for the game works. Here's a telling comment of his from the movelist for that game:
9. N !D7-c7 // Hi. Listen, I think maybe this preset might need a little // bit more work to become fully enforceable because it doesn't // appear to allow me to move your knight out of hostage // territory even as I rescue mine. It's miraculous how it // automatically enforces some of the rules. Unless I'm doing // something wrong, it needs work on some other aspects of the // rules.
The move he has written moves the Knight directly from the prison to the board, which is illegal. Judging by his comment, he expects the preset to automatically exchange Knights when he tries to drop his Knight on the board. If he tried 'N*c7' and it didn't work, this is because the Knight is still in the prison, not in the airfield. The preset will not automatically exchange pieces when you try to drop a piece from the prison, because it can't always know which piece you wish to exchange for your piece. Therefore, the exchange must be made explicit before dropping a piece that is still in prison. The legal notation for the intended move is 'n-N; N*c7'. I tested it by substituting it for the original move, and it worked as it is supposed to. Details on the notation for this preset are given in the Notation section, which you will see if you just page down the preset a bit.
Thank you for easing the play of one of my favorite games.
Well done, and it is appreciated.
I was reading the piece descriptions for Chu Shogi and noticed a couple of things that are not as how I learned to play the game a couple of weeks ago. It's probably just a typing mistake, but I want to make sure as I might be playing it incorrectly. The movement description for the Silver General in Chu Shogi is incorrect. The Silver General may move one square diagonally in any direction or one square straight ahead. The description given has it moving like a Bishop and the promoted piece isn't what a Silver General promotes to as it promotes to a Vertical Mover. The Copper General promotes to a Side Mover and not a Vertical Mover. The second column seems to have the promoted piece descriptions line up correctly. The description I'm talking about are in the first comlumn talking about the unpromoted piece. This is in the Latin part of the descriptions.
25 comments displayed
Permalink to the exact comments currently displayed.